This Blog is the Opinion of Rick Allison, the Author of: Designing an Investment Portfolio for American Patriots. Rick's Registered Investment Adviser web site is located at: www.marianfs.com.
Monday, January 24, 2011
SEC Staff Study on Investment Advisers and Broker-Dealers
http://www.sec.gov/news/studies/2011/913studyfinal.pdf
Everybody has opinions and I am no different. The views expressed herein are the opinions of Rick Johnson.
It appears to me that the SEC Staff is biased toward keeping the status quo. They recommend against eliminating the broker-dealer exclusion from the definition of "investment adviser" in the Advisers Act. They also recommend against applying the duty of care and other requirements of the Advisers Act to broker-dealers. The SEC Staff apparently believes that what registered representatives do is essentially the same thing as what investment adviser representatives do. I for one, beg to differ.
Investment Advice from a Wall Street firm
If you as a client were to walk into a Wall Street firm for investment advice, you will most likely be sold some combination of these products:
Stocks
Mutual Funds
Bonds
Variable Annuities
Unit Investment Trusts
Let me delve a little deeper into why I do not think this is good for investors. Wall Street firms routinely buy large blocks of shares of stock that they in turn sell to their customers. They may have bought the stock that they recommend to you at $30, but sell to you as a recommendation at $35. As an investor, you may be misled into believing that all the Wall Street firm made from the stock recommendation was the $29.95 they charged in trading commissions. Did you know this?
When mutual funds are recommended, in a lot of cases, the Wall Street firm recommends a favorite set of mutual funds. Technically, their compliance department only approves a limited number of mutual fund families that their registered representatives can recommend. Wouldn't you know it, the stock mutual funds that they recommend have a 5.75% sale commission on them.
When a Wall Street firm sells you some bonds, they charge a markup. Legally, they can charge you up to 5% markup on the bond. You as the investor do not see it, because it is built into the price of the bond. For example, if a bond's price is 100 to the Wall Street firm, they may sell it to you at 102.50. The registered representative usually doesn't bother to tell you this when he is recommending it. Most of the time, the registered representative probably does not even know what his Wall Street firm is making on each bond. However, I can guarantee you one thing. They are making money on the bonds they sell to investors.
Variable Annuities carry high commission charges and ten years or more surrender penalties. Oh, I almost forgot. They have high expenses, too. Did you know that you could pay a registered representative 6 to 8% in commissions if you buy a Variable Annuity from them? Did you know that there are Variable Annuities with no sales charges, no surrender penalties and low expenses? I wonder why your Wall Street firm registered representative did not tell you this?
Personally, I cannot stand to see Unit Investment Trusts in an investor's portfolio. Right away, I know that the investor may be locked into this investment for a period of time and there may be significant restrictions on selling the UIT as they are called. Most of these UIT's have a sales commission of 3.95% or so. They may defer some of it, because after all, they know that their investors are locked in to the investment anyway. This does not seem like much of a benefit to investors to me.
Strangely enough, I searched the entire SEC Staff Study and could not find one reference to quotas. Each Wall Street firm's registered representative has what is known as a revenue quota, or "nut to crack." This was an egregious omission in my opinion. Most of the large Wall Street firms require their registered representatives to produce $250,000 to $300,000 in revenue for the firm. How do they do this? By selling investors stocks, mutual funds, bonds, Variable Annuities and Unit Investment Trusts. It is really very simple to understand. Registered representatives for Wall Street firms have to produce revenue to keep their jobs. As a result, they sell products that make them the most revenue, not because they want to, but because they have to, otherwise they risk losing their job. Before you start feeling sorry for them, ask yourself "How does selling me products that pay high commissions benefit me and my goals, needs and objectives?" The truth is that it does not benefit you. It benefits the Wall Street firm first and their registered representative second. Investors are third on that list, unfortunately.
The last sentence of the Executive Summary of this SEC Staff Study says, "The Staff developed its recommendations with a view toward minimizing cost and disruption and assuring that retail investors continue to have access to various investment products and choice among compensation schemes to pay for advice." If you analyze this statement with with I just explained above you will see that the SEC Staff believes it is okay for you to be sold various investment products, (described above) choice among compensation schemes to pay for advice. (I think they mean commissions and fees.) I am curious as to their use of the word "schemes" in that sentence.
They are right about the investors having a choice. You can refuse to do business with any Wall Street firm whose first priority is themselves. This includes Banks who own most Wall Street firms today, too.
Monday, July 13, 2009
KYATMA Explained
I read a lot. These are some of the things that I read weekly or monthly as they are published.
Inside Information
Investment News Magazine
Investment Advisor Magazine
Financial Advisor Magazine
Financial Planning Magazine
Futures Magazine
Registered Representative Magazine
The Wall Street Journal
Senior Market Advisor
Benefits Selling Advisor
Life Insurance Selling
The Register
My wife tells me that I am all business, but I find time to read the Bible. The Bible is God's word and the works of Jesus Christ. We all need to read it more, myself included. I also read non-business books like The Noticer by Andy Andrews. Andy has a good blog. He is an inspirational writer that can make you focus on what is most important in life. http://www.andyandrews.com/blog/
What is my point? When I walk into a room full of my professional peers, I can easily see by their questions and responses that I am far ahead of them in wisdom. In these trade magazines that I read, they are becoming more like psychology magazines than they are financial magazines.
It appears that most financial advisors have failed miserably in their duties to their clients in protecting their investment portfolios. A ton of the stories that I read now are how to keep clients after you have done a lousy job for them. Other stories talk about how to deal with the stress of losing a large chunk of revenue as a result of your bad advice. Still others discuss ways to lay people off from work, again as a result of your bad advice.
What kills me is that this is all really simple when it comes down to it. If you are a client or a financial advisor, then listen up. There are two inevitable truths when it comes to the stock market.
- The stock market goes up.
- The stock market goes down.
You have to invest based on both of these two facts. It is really that simple.
Most every investment mistake can be traced to either an investor or a financial advisor believing only in number one above and completely ignoring number two.
In my book, I talk about how if you put more than 20% in any one asset class, then you are putting your entire investment portfolio at risk. In addition, I discuss how if you put more than 65% in the stock market, then you are also putting your entire investment portfolio at risk. When you combine the two, like for example, holding 50% in one stock (think Bank of America or GE) and the other 50% in four of five blue chip stocks, then you are doomed to failure. This portfolio will lose money at the first sign of a recession or bear market.
You have to invest based on the known fact that the stock market will go up and also go down. In my book, I have a plan and a process that you can follow that will help you manage money. Or, you can be one of the many fools who believe that they will make a killing by picking individual stocks.
Let me show you the fallacy of picking individual stocks. Pick a stock. Any stock. Let us choose one that is selling for $30 a share right now. You buy 1000 shares of it to start. Now, when do you sell? Do you sell when it is $35? Or, $40? If $40 is better, then why not $45? If $45 is better, than why not $50 or even $60? Whatever number on the upside we choose, once it hits our target price, then are we really going to sell it at that exact moment? Do we put in a limit order? Or, do we re-evaluate? Do we become a little greedier and raise our target and let winners run? Or, do we get out while the getting is good? These are only the questions related to when the stock goes up.
Now, let us consider the downside. When do we sell on the downside? Do we sell at $25 or $26? Or, do we sell at $27, $28 or even $29 a share? When it does hit our sell target, then what? Do we immediately buy another stock? Or, do we wait until we do some research? How long do we take to do our research? A day? A week? Two weeks? A month? Where do we park the money in the meantime? What if we are suddenly in a recession? What if we are in a bull market?
These are just some of the decisions that you have to make to invest in one stock. Now, imagine that you have to make 30 or 40 independent decisions just like these on your entire portfolio. Another point that I make in my book is if I pick 30 or 40 stocks, then I have effectively made my own personal index fund. The performance of my personal index fund is going to match the performance of the stock market. You cannot pick 30 or 40 stocks and they all be winners of 50% performance of higher. Some will win. Some will lose and the end result is that you will have built your own personal index fund, like I said. More than likely, you will have done a bad job at it, too.
If you follow the principles in my book and become a KYATMA follower, then you will have a plan and process that will give you more of an opportunity for success. There is one catch, however. You have to read my book.
Thanks.